Ideas

In Defense of Effeminate Boys

If anyone had suggested that I might really be a girl, I don’t know how I would have responded.

First published in The Atlantic on March 3, 2026.

by Ben Appel, The Atlantic
March 5, 2026 | reading time: 9 Min.

Growing up, I was quite the sissy boy. “Hey, Nancy,” people who called my family’s house would say if I happened to pick up the phone. Nancy is my mother’s name. “No, it’s her son, Ben,” I’d respond, and the caller would apologize profusely, as if there were no greater tragedy for a boy than being mistaken for a girl. But I didn’t know to feel this type of shame. I was raised in a fundamentalist Christian community called the Lamb of God, and—perhaps surprising—no one seemed to care about my flamboyance. What mattered was that my heart was on fire for the Lord.

© SZ - You can acquire rights to the article here.